The bulletin board for America's public schools. Parents, teachers, students, and staff. One community per school.
school safetyartificial intelligencelawsuitsmarylandpolice in schools

Students file lawsuit after Al mistakes Doritos bag for a gun

Mary Johnson
Contributing Author, allk12.com · Nov 19, 2026 · 12:11 PM ET
Students file lawsuit after Al mistakes Doritos bag for a gun
Credit: ABC 7 Chicago
See more of our coverage in your search results.Add allk12 on Google

School and police officials canceled an AI gun alert at Kenwood High School in Baltimore County, Maryland, within two minutes because the image showed a student holding a bag of Doritos. More than 10 minutes later, the principal sent a screenshot of that image to the school's police officer, and armed officers were sent anyway, according to a lawsuit filed November 17 by four current and former Kenwood students.

The students, all football players, sued in the Circuit Court for Baltimore County. They named Omnilert, the Virginia company whose gun-detection software scans the district's security cameras; Baltimore County, for its police department; the school board of Baltimore County Public Schools (BCPS); district school safety director Eric Knox; Kenwood principal Catherine "Kate" Smith; and eight officers, three not yet identified. The Lawyers' Committee for Civil Rights Under Law, one of the students' legal teams, says all four are Black.

Kenwood High had 1,900 students in grades 9 to 12 in 2024-25, according to allk12's analysis of federal data. About 40.7% were Black, 27.4% White, and 22.3% Hispanic, and 66.4% were eligible for free or reduced-price lunch.

According to the complaint, the coach handed out bags of Doritos after practice on October 20, 2025. Taki Allen, then a junior, and three seniors waited near picnic tables by the back entrance for a ride. Shortly before 7:04 p.m., Omnilert's system flagged the bag in Allen's hand as a firearm "with 90% confidence," the complaint says. Omnilert's human reviewers verified it, and a text alert went to 15 people, five at BCPS and 10 at the police department.

Between 7:05 and 7:06 p.m., Knox, a district safety manager, and a police sergeant saw no gun and canceled the alert, and every recipient got a second text saying so, the suit says. Between 7:17 and 7:19 p.m., Smith opened the alert link, which showed the cancellation, enlarged the video, and sent a screenshot to school resource officer John Douglas on his personal phone, according to the complaint. Douglas forwarded it to the police precinct.

At 7:19 p.m., the complaint says, Smith texted two district administrators: "Omni alert is working. Kid standing on my patio right now. Looks like one of mine and looks like he's armed. My SRO is calling it into the precinct now." When Douglas texted that the object "looks like a blue gun," Smith replied, "Right, but maybe not." Officers were dispatched at 7:21 p.m.

At least six cruisers arrived, and several officers drew their guns, the suit says. Officers ordered the four students onto their knees, kept them handcuffed for at least six minutes, and searched them and their backpacks. They found no weapons. As he left, the supervising corporal told the students, "Hey, thanks for not running away, that would have been a real problem." Another officer swore about Omnilert and muttered "stupid AI cameras," according to the complaint. Later that night, it says, Douglas texted Smith that it was a "bag of chips not a gun," and her reply began "Bwahahaha."

"It was mainly like, am I gonna die or are they gonna kill me because they were all pointing their guns at me and I'm not used to all those guns being pointed at me," Allen said. The complaint says he now often pays for car services rather than wait outside the school for a ride.

What the state inspector general found

The Maryland Office of the Inspector General for Education reported on the incident on November 25, 2025. It said BCPS gets about 12 alerts a day after Omnilert's staff review them. In district data from November 2023 to November 2025, the office found "fewer than 1% of alerts forwarded to BCPS by Omnilert required notifying law enforcement." The lawsuit describes that as a false-positive rate of more than 99%.

The report found no bias in the software, which it said "focuses solely on the moving object." It said the student's hand position and angle, with an object extending slightly past his fingers, set off the alert, "not a single potato chip bag." The principal told investigators she noticed the cancellation only after police had cleared the school grounds. The office found that enlarging the image or video "could cause the user to overlook the cancellation text message," and that any recipient could get around a cancellation "by simply making a phone call or sending a text message" to police.

It recommended that BCPS alert its own staff first and bring in police only after a threat is confirmed, with training twice a year. BCPS said then, "BCPS will adopt the report's recommendations," and that all administrators had been retrained in November 2025. The complaint says the system still runs at Kenwood and the policies behind the incident "remain in place."

BCPS budgeted $560,000 a year for Omnilert's monitoring service, according to the report. Divided among the 110,066 students the district counted on September 30, 2024, that comes to $5.09 per student per year. The district put the system in all 165 of its schools between fall 2023 and spring 2024, the complaint says.

What the suit asks for and what the defendants say

The complaint brings 11 counts, including unreasonable search and seizure, false arrest, negligence, and gross negligence against Smith. It asks for compensatory and punitive damages set by a jury and an order barring BCPS and the county from using Omnilert's system or any similar AI gun detection "unless and until adequate verification protocols, cancelation and communication procedures, and training are adopted and implemented."

In October 2025, an Omnilert spokesperson said "the system operated as designed," and Baltimore County police said, "The officers responded appropriately and proportionally based on the information provided at the time."

This week, Omnilert said, "What these four students went through on October 20, 2025 should not have happened, and we are truly sorry for the fear they and their families experienced." It said district staff canceled the alert within about two minutes. "That is exactly why human review matters, and why a canceled alert must stay canceled," the company said, adding that it will respond in court. BCPS said it cannot comment on pending litigation, and county police said they had no comment. No response from Smith has been reported.

The stamped complaint posted by the Lawyers' Committee shows no case number yet, and no hearing date has been reported. Separately, a 2025 Maryland law requires the Maryland Center for School Safety to study the most effective ways to detect deadly weapons in public middle and high schools, with a final report due December 1, 2026, according to the inspector general's report.

Sources
Lawyers' Committee for Civil Rights Under Law: Allen v. Omnilert complaint, Circuit Court for Baltimore County, filed November 17, 2026
Lawyers' Committee for Civil Rights Under Law: Lawyers' Committee files lawsuit on behalf of Black students detained and searched due to AI alert
Maryland Office of the Inspector General for Education: Investigative Synopsis, OIGE Case 25-0014-I, November 25, 2025
The Baltimore Banner: Students sue Baltimore County schools after AI weapons detection system mistook chips for gun
FOX45: Students sue Baltimore Co. schools and AI company after bag of chips mistaken for a gun
WMAR-2 News: Lawsuit filed after AI system mistakes chips for gun at Kenwood High
CBS News Baltimore: A.I. gun detection false alarm at school has Baltimore County leaders calling for review
WMAR-2 News: Police defend response to false AI generated gun scare at Kenwood High School
WMAR-2 News: State officials say AI system didn't discriminate based on color when mistaking students' chip bag for gun
School enrollment and demographics from allk12's analysis of National Center for Education Statistics (NCES) Common Core of Data, 2024-25.

Frequently asked questions

What is the Kenwood High Doritos lawsuit about?
Four current and former Kenwood High students say officers drew guns, handcuffed them, and searched them on October 20, 2025, after Omnilert's AI flagged a bag of Doritos as a gun. The complaint says officials had already canceled the alert.
How often do Omnilert alerts in Baltimore County schools lead to police?
Rarely. Maryland's Inspector General for Education found that from November 2023 to November 2025, fewer than 1% of Omnilert alerts sent to Baltimore County Public Schools required notifying police. The district gets about 12 alerts a day after Omnilert's review.
What happens next in the case?
The suit was filed November 17, 2026, in the Circuit Court for Baltimore County, and the students want a jury trial. Omnilert says it will respond in court. No hearing date has been reported, and the school district says it cannot comment.
LOADING COMMENTS…
WRITTEN BY
Mary Johnson
Mary Johnson
Contributing Author, allk12.com

Mary Johnson spent several years as a substitute teacher across elementary and middle school classrooms before moving into education writing.

EXPERTISE
Classroom behavior and student engagementHomework habits and study routinesParent communication with schoolsSubstitute and part-time teaching dynamics