The bulletin board for America's public schools. Parents, teachers, students, and staff. One community per school.
charter schoolpublic schoolschool choiceparents

Charter school vs. public school: a charter is public, but it runs on a contract

Kate Carter
Former Educator · Jun 14, 2026 · 12:33 PM ET
Charter school vs. public school: a charter is public, but it runs on a contract
See more of our coverage in your search results.Add allk12 on Google

A charter school is a public school. It is free, paid for with tax dollars, and open to any eligible student, but an independent board runs it under a contract, called a charter, instead of the local school district. The charter frees the school from many district rules, and the school can be closed if it misses the goals the contract sets.

There were 8,214 charter schools with 3,950,158 students in the 2024-25 school year, about 8% of the country's 49.1 million public school students, according to federal data. That share was 4% in fall 2010 and 7% in fall 2021, the National Center for Education Statistics reported. The 2024-25 federal data lists charters in 44 states and Washington, D.C., and the National Alliance for Public Charter Schools counts 46 states with laws that allow them. Our list of which states have the most charter schools breaks the numbers down by state.

Charter schoolTraditional public schoolPrivate school
TuitionFreeFreeCharged, though some states offer vouchers or scholarships
Who runs itAn independent board, often with a nonprofit operatorThe local school boardA private board, owner, or religious body
Who can enrollAny eligible student; a lottery when seats run shortChildren in the attendance zoneWhoever the school admits
FundingPublic per-student money, about 75 cents per district dollar on averageFederal, state, and local taxesMostly tuition and donations
State testsRequiredRequiredUsually not required
Who oversees itAn authorizer that can close itThe district and the stateLimited state oversight

Rules vary by state, and a charter in Arizona runs under very different conditions than one in Massachusetts. The table shows the general pattern.

What changes for your child

Getting in. A district school takes every child in its attendance zone. A charter has no zone. Families apply, and when more students apply than there are seats, the school fills them by random lottery, often with a preference for siblings of current students. Charters cannot charge tuition or choose students by grades or test scores. A school that charges tuition is a private school, even if it calls itself an academy.

Who is in charge. Charters are approved and monitored by authorizers, which are usually public agencies such as local school districts or state education departments, the National Alliance says. Authorizers can approve, renew, or close a charter based on its academic, financial, and operational record. Most charters, 62%, are single-site schools. The rest belong to networks, called charter management organizations, such as KIPP, which run many schools on a shared model.

Money. On average, charter schools receive 75 cents for every dollar a traditional district receives, according to the National Alliance, mostly because most charters get no local tax money for buildings. Some make up the gap with donations, and some do not.

Rules. A charter can set a longer school day, write its own curriculum, hire teachers outside the district's seniority system, or build itself around a model such as classical education or dual-language immersion. It still has to give state tests, serve students with disabilities, follow civil rights law, and report its results.

Accountability. A district school that struggles for years usually stays open. A charter that misses its goals can lose its charter when it comes up for renewal, and money trouble counts too: a North Las Vegas charter school faced losing its charter after defaulting on the bond it used to buy its building. How strictly authorizers use that power varies a lot from state to state.

Charters also differ from magnet schools, which are run by districts, are built around a theme, and sometimes admit students by grades, auditions, or tests. We cover the research on those in our look at magnet schools.

Do charter students learn more?

On average, a little. The largest national study, from Stanford University's Center for Research on Education Outcomes (CREDO), compared charter students with similar students in nearby district schools using data from 29 states, D.C., and New York City from 2014-15 to 2018-19. Charter students gained the equivalent of 16 more days of learning in reading and 6 more days in math each school year. Black and Hispanic students and students in poverty grew faster in charters than their district peers. Students in special education gained less.

The type of charter mattered. Schools run by charter management organizations added 27 days in reading and 23 in math. Stand-alone charters added 10 days in reading and matched district schools in math. Results also swung by place: across the 31 states and cities studied, the gap between the best and worst was 109 days of learning in reading and 120 in math. At the school level, 36% of charters beat their local district schools in both subjects, while 17% trailed in reading and 25% in math.

The study has critics. A review for the National Education Policy Center by Joseph J. Ferrare said its design is "unable to fully account for the factors that drive families to choose charter schools," since families who apply to charters may differ from those who do not.

For one family, the average matters less than the school down the street. Look at a charter's state test scores over several years, not one, and compare them with the district school your child would otherwise attend. Ask whether the charter has been renewed and whether its authorizer raised concerns, how many teachers left last year, and how it serves students with disabilities and English learners. Every public school, charter or district, has a profile and test-score history on allk12, and the charter school growth by state report tracks where enrollment is rising. Families also weighing private school can see where private school is and is not worth the money.

Sources
National Center for Education Statistics: Public Charter School Enrollment (Condition of Education)
National Alliance for Public Charter Schools: About Charter Schools
Stanford CREDO: National Charter School Study III press release (June 6, 2023)
National Education Policy Center: Review of National Charter School Study III
School counts and enrollment from allk12's analysis of National Center for Education Statistics (NCES) Common Core of Data, 2024-25.

Frequently asked questions

Is a charter school a public school?
Yes. Charter schools are free public schools paid for with tax dollars and open to any eligible student. An independent board runs each one under a contract, called a charter, that frees it from some district rules in exchange for meeting set goals.
Do you have to pay for a charter school?
No. Charter schools cannot charge tuition. They run on public per-student funding, which averages about 75 cents for every dollar a district receives, the National Alliance for Public Charter Schools says. A school that charges tuition is a private school.
Are charter schools better than regular public schools?
On average, slightly. Stanford's CREDO found charter students gained 16 more days of learning in reading and 6 in math per year than similar district students from 2014-15 to 2018-19. Results vary widely from school to school.
LOADING COMMENTS…
WRITTEN BY
Kate Carter
Kate Carter
Former Educator

Kate Carter spent nearly 20 years in public school classrooms before transitioning to education writing and curriculum consulting. She taught middle and high school English and social studies across two states.

EXPERTISE
K-12 curriculum and instructionEducation Policy