Erin Menefee, 42, a deacon at Oakridge Baptist Church in Albany, Georgia, was arrested on reckless conduct charges after police say he put four children off the church's bus and left them at an Albany intersection on Sunday, October 11, 2026, according to an Albany Police Department incident report. The report identifies him as a teacher at Mitchell County High School in Camilla.
Menefee told officers he had about 20 children on the bus, that the four were being disruptive, and that he needed to put them off the bus for his safety, according to the report. Asked how he expected the children to get home, he said he had called their grandmother. Police said he acknowledged he should have waited for someone to pick them up. He has been charged, not convicted.
The children were three siblings, ages 12, 11, and 9, and a 10-year-old friend the family had invited to church, the report says. Officers were called to the church that Sunday. The siblings' mother told them her own mother had called to say Menefee phoned and said he put the children off the bus because they were cursing.
The mother told police she was told the children had been left at the intersection of Westover Boulevard and Gillionville Road, which she said was too far for them to walk home. She drove around looking for them and could not find them. She did spot the church bus and tried to flag it down, according to the report, and police said Menefee told her he had left the children down the road.
She then went to the church to talk with the pastor. While there, she got a call saying a stranger had brought the children home, police said. In the report, the grandmother said she was told the children were put off the bus for cursing and hitting each other, and that the bus driver "don’t play that."
Officers then arrested Menefee. WALB reported that he is charged with multiple counts of reckless conduct. Atlanta Black Star reported that he faces four counts, that he was taken to the Dougherty County Jail, and that he later posted bond. Authorities have not alleged that the children were physically hurt, Atlanta Black Star reported.
Georgia's reckless conduct law, O.C.G.A. 16-5-60(b), covers a person who causes bodily harm to or endangers the bodily safety of another person by consciously disregarding a substantial and unjustifiable risk, in a way that falls far short of how a reasonable person would act. It is a misdemeanor. Under O.C.G.A. 17-10-3, a Georgia misdemeanor is punishable by up to 12 months in jail, a fine of up to $1,000, or both.
Atlanta Black Star reported on October 16 that no court date had been made public. As of November 16, no court date, indictment, or dismissal had been reported, and no statement from Menefee or a lawyer for him had been made public. Mitchell County Schools had posted nothing about the arrest on its district news page, and the high school's online staff directory still listed an Erin Menefee. The district has not said publicly whether his job status changed.
Mitchell County High School enrolled 334 students in grades 9 through 12 in 2024-25, with 38.6 full-time-equivalent teachers (part-time staff count as fractions), according to allk12's analysis of federal data. That is down from 460 students in 2017-18, a drop of 126 students, or about 27% (126 divided by 460). Of its 334 students, 258, or about 77%, qualified for free or reduced-price lunch.
The high school is one of four schools in the Mitchell County district, which enrolled 1,203 students in 2024-25. Three of those schools, including the high school, are in Camilla. More district and school data is on the Georgia schools page.
Sources
WALB: Bus driver for Oakridge Baptist Church arrested for leaving kids on side of road in Albany
Atlanta News First: Church deacon, teacher arrested for reportedly kicking children off bus, leaving them on side of road
Local 12: Teacher, deacon accused of ordering children off bus for cussing, leaving them on roadside
Atlanta Black Star: Georgia deacon kicks 'misbehaving' kids off church bus, leaving them stranded on side of road, police say
FindLaw: Georgia Code 16-5-60, reckless conduct
FindLaw: Georgia Code 17-10-3, punishment for misdemeanors
Mitchell County Schools: District news
Mitchell County High School: Staff directory
Enrollment, teacher, and lunch figures from allk12's analysis of National Center for Education Statistics (NCES) Common Core of Data, 2017-18 and 2024-25.



