Community prompt from u/allk12. Replies below.
PS 58 CARROLL (THE)
Test scores
NYS Assessments 2024-25 . % Proficient (Level 3 + Level 4)What this means: On the NYS Assessments, New York's statewide test, about 88 of every 100 students at this school read and write at grade level and about 87 of 100 do math at grade level. Across all New York schools, those numbers are about 58 and 57. Reading and writing scores are up about 11 points since 2023, while math scores are up about 6 points.
BeatsExpectations
Demographically-adjusted score · methodologyWhat this means: About 80% of students here test proficient in math and reading, compared with the roughly 71% typical for New York schools with a similar share of low-income students. BeatsExpectations measures results against demographically similar schools rather than by raw scores, and this school falls within the typical range, neither among New York's top nor bottom 10%.
7-year change
SY 2017-18 vs SY 2024-25About PS 58 CARROLL (THE)
PS 58 CARROLL (THE), a roomy elementary campus in BROOKLYN, New York, run under NEW YORK CITY GEOGRAPHIC DISTRICT #15, works with 753 students, covering grades pre-K through 5. That puts it 70% larger than the typical public school in New York, which averages around 443 students.
Across the 51 schools in NEW YORK CITY GEOGRAPHIC DISTRICT #15 (25,925 students total), PS 58 CARROLL (THE) accounts for its share of the district's footprint.
Looking at the student body, PS 58 CARROLL (THE) lists that 67% of the student body identifies as White. Beyond that, the school shows 12% multiracial, 11% Hispanic, 5% Asian, 5% Black. By comparison, Kings County as a whole is about 38% White, so the school skews considerably more White than its surroundings.
On the resource side, PS 58 CARROLL (THE) lists 46 full-time-equivalent teachers, putting the student-to-teacher ratio at about 16.4:1. The state averages around 12.8:1, so this campus is higher than the state norm typical. Roughly 11% of students at PS 58 CARROLL (THE) qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, which schools and policymakers use as a rough income-mix signal. Set against Kings County (around 79%), the school's rate is somewhat below typical.
After controlling for student poverty, PS 58 CARROLL (THE) performs roughly as the BeatsExpectations model predicts for a school with this FRL share. The predicted value is around 71.0%, the actual is 79.8%, a residual of +8.7 points.
Around the school, the surrounding county (Kings County) logs that the typical household earns roughly $80,263 per year, about 42% of the adult population holds a bachelor's degree or above, and roughly 15% of residents live below the federal poverty line. PS 58 CARROLL (THE) is one of 583 public schools in Kings County (combined enrollment of about 291,697 students).
PS 32 SAMUEL MILLS SPROLE is the nearest neighboring public school, about 0.2 miles from this campus. Within five miles, there are 8 other public schools. On composite proficiency, PS 58 CARROLL (THE) comes 2nd of 8 in the immediate cluster, higher than the nearby-schools average of 59.9%.
The school occupies a high-density site.
Over the past 7-year window. Looking back 7 years, enrollment at PS 58 CARROLL (THE) has decreased 24%, going from 988 students in 2018 to 753 in 2025. Over the same period, the White share contracted from 74% to 67%. Class-load math has loosened: from 14.7:1 in 2018 to 16.4:1 in 2025.
Within the allk12 community for this school, the page collects discussion, questions, and updates around open house dates, ride-share offers, and field-trip permission slips. Contributors range from current parents to recent graduates and teachers.
Kings County at a glance
View full county profileQuick facts
Related schools
- SUNSET PARK HIGH SCHOOLHigh · 1,348 students
- PS 321 WILLIAM PENNElementary · 1,305 students
- MS 51 WILLIAM ALEXANDERMiddle · 1,038 students
- PS 230 DORIS L COHENElementary · 925 students
- PS 130 PARKSIDE (THE)Elementary · 891 students
- BROOKLYN HIGH SCHOOL OF THE ARTSHigh · 890 students
- BROOKLYN TECHNICAL HIGH SCHOOLHigh · 5,848 students
- FORT HAMILTON HIGH SCHOOLHigh · 4,044 students
- JAMES MADISON HIGH SCHOOLHigh · 3,983 students
- MIDWOOD HIGH SCHOOLHigh · 3,657 students
- EDWARD R MURROW HIGH SCHOOLHigh · 3,503 students
- FRANKLIN DELANO ROOSEVELT HIGH SCHOOLHigh · 3,403 students
- PS 32 SAMUEL MILLS SPROLE0.2 mi · 481
- NEW DAWN CHARTER HIGH SCHOOL0.3 mi · 223
- BROOKLYN NEW SCHOOL-PS 146 (THE)0.3 mi · 634
- BROOKLYN COLLABORATIVE STUDIES0.3 mi · 586
- BOERUM HILL SCHOOL FOR INTERNATIONAL STUDIES (THE)0.4 mi · 743
- SUCCESS ACADEMY CHARTER SCHOOL-COBBLE HILL0.4 mi · 260