allk12 · Rankings · Lowest proficiency · Michigan · Saginaw County

The lowest-performing public schools by test proficiency in Saginaw County, Michigan

24 public schools in Saginaw County, Michigan appear in this ranking of the lowest-performing public schools by test proficiency, ranked by the lowest composite state-assessment proficiency. Carrollton Middle School leads the list at 21.9%, against a median of 47.1% across the ranked schools.

The table below is sortable and filterable, and the full list downloads as a CSV. Figures come from federal NCES enrollment data and, where applicable, state assessment results for 2024-25.

Schools ranked

Saginaw County, Michigan

Best % Proficient

21.9%

Median % Proficient

47.1%

LOWEST PROFICIENCY · SAGINAW COUNTY, MICHIGAN

#	School	City	District	Level	% FRL	Students	% Proficient
1	Carrollton Middle School	SAGINAW, MI	Carrollton Public Schools	Middle	82.6%	344	21.9%
2	Carrollton Elementary School	SAGINAW, MI	Carrollton Public Schools	Elementary	85.2%	662	24.6%
3	North Saginaw Charter Academy	SAGINAW, MI	North Saginaw Charter Academy	Elementary	95.4%	679	25.9%
4	Arrowwood Elementary School	SAGINAW, MI	Saginaw Township Community Schools	Elementary	58.7%	445	28.6%
5	Weiss Elementary School	SAGINAW, MI	Saginaw Township Community Schools	Elementary	60.5%	357	29.3%
6	Chester F Miller School	SAGINAW, MI	Saginaw School District of the City of	Elementary	89.9%	247	30.6%
7	White Pine Middle School	SAGINAW, MI	Saginaw Township Community Schools	Middle	48.4%	1,019	33.8%
8	North Elementary School	BIRCH RUN, MI	Birch Run Area Schools	Elementary	58.7%	682	35.2%
9	Marshall Greene Middle School	BIRCH RUN, MI	Birch Run Area Schools	Middle	52.6%	548	37.4%
10	Merrill Elementary School	MERRILL, MI	Merrill Community Schools	Elementary	59.2%	196	42.8%
11	St Charles Elementary School	SAINT CHARLES, MI	St. Charles Community Schools	Elementary	71.9%	317	44.0%
12	Chesaning Middle School	CHESANING, MI	Chesaning Union Schools	Middle	56.7%	584	46.8%
13	KC Ling Elementary School	HEMLOCK, MI	Hemlock Public School District	Elementary	29.9%	365	47.4%
14	Big Rock Elementary School	CHESANING, MI	Chesaning Union Schools	Elementary	57.0%	393	48.0%
15	Hemlock Middle School	HEMLOCK, MI	Hemlock Public School District	Middle	24.9%	350	52.3%
16	Freeland Middle SchoolHigh School	FREELAND, MI	Freeland Community School District	High	19.4%	897	54.8%
17	Swan Valley Middle School	SAGINAW, MI	Swan Valley School District	Middle	32.1%	408	55.4%
18	Lorenz C List School	FRANKENMUTH, MI	Frankenmuth School District	Elementary	17.7%	479	56.0%
19	EF Rittmueller Middle School	FRANKENMUTH, MI	Frankenmuth School District	Middle	18.8%	368	57.6%
20	Robert B Havens Elem School	SAGINAW, MI	Swan Valley School District	Elementary	32.6%	390	60.9%
21	Freeland Elementary School	FREELAND, MI	Freeland Community School District	Elementary	21.1%	755	62.5%
22	Handley School	SAGINAW, MI	Saginaw School District of the City of	Elementary	42.7%	370	72.5%
23	Saginaw Arts and Sciences Academy	SAGINAW, MI	Saginaw School District of the City of	High	45.2%	374	75.8%
24	Hemmeter Elementary School	SAGINAW, MI	Saginaw Township Community Schools	Elementary	12.4%	331	79.5%

Page 1 of 1 · top 24 of 24 ranked. NCES + state assessment data, 2024-25.↓ Download full CSV

All schools in Saginaw County →

Lowest proficiency rankings at a wider scope

All Michigan Nationwide

Other rankings for Saginaw County, Michigan

Largest Most diverse Lowest ratio Highest proficiency Fastest growing Highest poverty Lowest poverty Highest ratio Fastest declining Most Hispanic Most Black Most White Most Asian

All ranking categories →

DATA NOTICE

allk12 is independent and not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by NCES, the US Census Bureau, any state education agency or assessment program, or any other government agency. Source data is compiled from public records and provided "as is," without warranty of accuracy or completeness. You rely on it, and any analysis derived from it, at your own risk. See the full disclaimer.