MARGARET W CUYLER ELEMENTARY SCHOOL
School pathway
Test scores
NYS Assessments 2024-25 . % Proficient (Level 3 + Level 4)What this means: On the NYS Assessments, New York's statewide test, about 36 of every 100 students at this school read and write at grade level and about 52 of 100 do math at grade level. Across all New York schools, those numbers are about 58 and 57. Reading and writing scores are up about 9 points since 2023, while math scores are up about 13 points.
BeatsExpectations
Demographically-adjusted score · methodologyWhat this means: About 36% of students here test proficient in math and reading, below the roughly 56% typical for New York schools with a similar share of low-income students. BeatsExpectations compares each school with others at the same poverty level, not by raw scores, so a school lands here when its results trail those comparable schools, which is not the same as having low scores. A higher-scoring school can still fall in this tier if similar schools score higher still.
7-year change
SY 2017-18 vs SY 2024-25About MARGARET W CUYLER ELEMENTARY SCHOOL
MARGARET W CUYLER ELEMENTARY SCHOOL is a primary school of close-knit scale in RED CREEK, New York, run under RED CREEK CENTRAL SCHOOL DISTRICT, educateing 350 students in grades pre-K through 5. Compared to the state average of about 443 students per school, that is 21% leaner than typical.
Across the 3 schools in RED CREEK CENTRAL SCHOOL DISTRICT (783 students total), MARGARET W CUYLER ELEMENTARY SCHOOL accounts for its share of the district's footprint.
Demographically, MARGARET W CUYLER ELEMENTARY SCHOOL shows that the student body is overwhelmingly White (97%); the rest consists of 3% multiracial. By comparison, Wayne County as a whole is about 88% White, so the school skews visibly more White than its surroundings.
Looking at school resources, The school employs 44 full-time-equivalent teachers, for a student-teacher ratio near 8.0:1. That figure is tighter than the state norm's 12.8:1 average. Roughly 51% of students at MARGARET W CUYLER ELEMENTARY SCHOOL qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, which schools and policymakers use as a rough income-mix signal.
Adjusting for the school's free-and-reduced-lunch share, MARGARET W CUYLER ELEMENTARY SCHOOL falls in the UNDERPERFORMING tier of the BeatsExpectations residual. Given its student profile, a typical campus would land near 56.4%; this one comes in at 36.1%, -20.3 points off the demographic line.
In the surrounding community, ACS estimates for Wayne County put median household income runs about $74,506, 26% of adults hold a bachelor's degree or higher, and the poverty rate sits near 7%. Across Wayne County's 37 public schools (combined enrollment of about 13,068 students), MARGARET W CUYLER ELEMENTARY SCHOOL is one campus in the mix.
The closest other public school is RED CREEK MIDDLE SCHOOL, roughly 0.2 miles away. Counting just inside five miles, 2 other public schools cluster around MARGARET W CUYLER ELEMENTARY SCHOOL. On composite proficiency, MARGARET W CUYLER ELEMENTARY SCHOOL comes 7th of 9 in the immediate cluster, beneath the nearby-schools average of 44.0%.
Geographically, the school is in a countryside area.
Looking at the recent track record. Looking back 7 years, enrollment at MARGARET W CUYLER ELEMENTARY SCHOOL has fell 19%, going from 432 students in 2018 to 350 in 2025. Class-load math has fell: from 11.1:1 in 2018 to 8.0:1 in 2025.
On the community side, recent activity here tends to focus on classroom updates, athletics, and weather closures. The community welcomes input from current and former families.
Wayne County at a glance
View full county profileQuick facts
Related schools
- RED CREEK HIGH SCHOOLHigh · 263 students
- RED CREEK MIDDLE SCHOOLMiddle · 170 students
- RED CREEK HIGH SCHOOLHigh · 263 students
- RED CREEK MIDDLE SCHOOLMiddle · 170 students
- RED CREEK MIDDLE SCHOOL0.2 mi · 170
- RED CREEK HIGH SCHOOL0.2 mi · 263
- NORTH ROSE-WOLCOTT MIDDLE SCHOOL5.2 mi · 309
- NORTH ROSE-WOLCOTT HIGH SCHOOL6.7 mi · 326
- KENNEY MIDDLE SCHOOL8.6 mi · 379
- FAIRLEY SCHOOL8.8 mi · 495