The bulletin board for America's public schools. Parents, teachers, students, and staff. One community per school.
MATH vs READING · INDIANA

Indiana: where math and reading scores diverge

Indiana public schools with the widest gap between math and reading proficiency. Same students, same test, only the subject changes.

Schools in this report
40
widest divergence in state
Most reading-ahead
-27 pp
Indiana Agriculture and Technology
Most math-ahead
+30 pp
Topeka Elementary School
IN PUBLIC SCHOOLS · WIDEST MATH-READING DIVERGENCE
SchoolCityLevelMath %Reading %Math − Reading (pp)
Indiana Agriculture and TechnologyCarmelHigh9.3%36.1%-26.8
Rochester Community High SchoolRochesterHigh14.3%41.1%-26.8
North Daviess Jr-Sr High SchoolElnoraHigh18.4%41.8%-23.4
Hagerstown Jr-Sr High SchoolHagerstownHigh32.3%52.4%-20
Westview Jr-Sr High SchoolTopekaHigh64.3%44.6%19.7
Cowan Elementary SchoolMuncieElementary47.9%28.2%19.8
Parkview Elementary SchoolBedfordElementary62.1%42.0%20.1
Porter Lakes Elementary SchoolHebronElementary72.5%52.3%20.2
Frank H Wheeler Elementary Sch 4SpeedwayElementary69.8%49.4%20.4
Perry Central Elementary SchoolLeopoldElementary58.4%38.1%20.4
Westwood Elementary SchoolNew CastleElementary63.9%43.4%20.5
Graham Creek Elementary SchoolCommiskeyElementary67.9%47.0%20.9
Mary Adams Elementary SchoolIndianapolisElementary69.5%48.0%21.5
Mill Creek West ElementaryAmoElementary66.3%44.8%21.5
Fairmont Elementary SchoolNew AlbanyElementary47.7%26.2%21.5
Thompson Crossing Elementary SchIndianapolisElementary55.2%33.6%21.6
Shipshewana-Scott Elementary SchShipshewanaElementary68.8%47.1%21.7
Hailmann Elementary SchoolLaPorteElementary58.7%37.0%21.7
York Elementary SchoolBristolElementary61.8%39.7%22.1
Monon Trail Elementary SchoolWestfieldElementary82.8%60.7%22.1
South Central Elementary SchoolUnion MillsElementary68.4%46.1%22.2
Yorktown Elementary SchoolYorktownElementary59.5%37.2%22.3
Daleville Elementary SchoolDalevilleElementary52.4%30.0%22.4
Waterloo Elementary SchoolWaterlooElementary42.7%20.2%22.5
West Noble Elementary SchoolLigonierElementary43.6%20.2%23.4
New Market Elementary SchoolNew MarketElementary63.8%40.4%23.4
Brooklyn STEM AcademyBrooklynElementary56.9%33.3%23.6
Northeast Dubois Intermediate SchoolDuboisElementary63.0%39.2%23.8
Van Buren Elementary SchoolBrazilElementary65.1%41.3%23.8
George Bibich Elementary SchoolDyerElementary75.3%50.5%24.7
Elberfeld Elementary SchoolElberfeldElementary81.5%56.5%25
Eden Elementary SchoolGreenfieldElementary78.1%53.1%25
Lake Prairie Elementary SchoolLowellElementary79.2%53.5%25.7
Chrisney Elementary SchoolChrisneyElementary73.2%46.9%26.4
Liberty Elementary SchoolHobartElementary60.5%33.3%27.2
Barr Reeve Elementary SchoolMontgomeryElementary72.4%45.2%27.2
Holland Elementary SchoolHollandElementary77.9%50.0%27.9
Bunker Hill Elementary SchoolIndianapolisElementary71.0%42.8%28.3
Rosedale Elementary SchoolRosedaleElementary60.5%32.1%28.4
Topeka Elementary SchoolTopekaElementary66.7%37.1%29.5
40 of 40 rows · Brick-and-mortar only; virtual schools and specialized-population schools excluded. Most recent year with both a math and a reading all-students result; schools must have 150+ students and at least 5% proficient in each subject (a floor that drops suppression/coding artifacts). A negative gap means students are more often proficient in reading than math.↓ Download math-reading-gap-by-state-in.csv

How to read this list

Each school is scored on its most recent year carrying both a math and a reading (English Language Arts) all-students proficiency figure on Indiana's native assessment. The final column is the difference: math proficiency minus reading proficiency, in percentage points. A negative number means a school's students are more often proficient in reading than in math; a positive number means the reverse. Because both figures come from the same students taking the same test under the same cut-score policy, the gap is an apples-to-apples comparison in a way that raw cross-state proficiency rates are not.

A wide gap is not automatically a problem. Arts, language-immersion, and humanities-focused programs often post strong reading and weaker math; STEM and career-technical programs often do the reverse. But a persistent, schoolwide divergence is worth a parent's attention, because it can also flag a staffing gap, a curriculum weakness, or a math-anxiety culture that a single year of scores would hide.

What is excluded

Brick-and-mortar schools only: virtual academies and cyber charters are removed because their results are noisy and rarely reflect a school families choose geographically. Specialized-population schools (state schools for the deaf or blind, therapeutic and juvenile-justice placements, and NCES special-education or alternative-education campuses) are also excluded, because state proficiency rates are not a comparable metric for them. Schools must have at least 150 students and at least 5% proficient in each subject, a floor that drops suppression and coding artifacts.

Source data

Indiana state assessment results loaded into allk12, joined to the NCES Common Core of Data school directory. Refreshed when the state publishes a new assessment file. See the national report for the state-by-state summary.

HOW TO CITE THIS REPORT

Anyone is welcome to cite or republish these findings. Please credit allk12.com and link back to this page so readers can verify the underlying data.

allk12 (2026). "Indiana: the math vs reading proficiency gap by school." Retrieved from https://allk12.com/reports/math-reading-gap/indiana
For interview requests or custom data pulls: [email protected]
DOWNLOAD THE DATA
math-reading-gap-by-state-in.csv
RELATED
Math vs reading gap by state · Indiana test scores · Best Indiana schools · All Indiana schools
DATA NOTICE

allk12 is independent and not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by NCES, the US Census Bureau, any state education agency or assessment program, or any other government agency. Source data is compiled from public records and provided "as is," without warranty of accuracy or completeness. You rely on it, and any analysis derived from it, at your own risk. See the full disclaimer.